
Well, I just got round to watching the very last episode of Stargate Atlantis and, while I have to say it contained some very good ideas, the execution of some of them was just terrible. But then, thinking about it, I don’t think there’s been a really good episode of Atlantis since the first series.
When Stargate Atlantis started five years ago, it was a refreshing change from the old Stargate SG-1 series. Rather than being safely on earth, the characters were stranded in a distant galaxy with no weapons and an impending attack from a seemingly unstoppable horde of hostile aliens. The entire first series formed a complex 20-part story arc. Even episodes that seemed like filler at the time ended up being tied into important events. But the real appeal of the show was the sense of isolation. Without any contact with earth there was literally nowhere to run to.
Then season 2 came along and everyone started running back and forward between Atlantis and Earth willy-nilly, and the isolation went out the window, as did anything that separated the show from SG-1. Gone were the complex story-arcs, and in came the filler episodes by the bucketload. The show was still entertaining, but it had really lost that spark that made me feel I had to watch it every week. Overall, season 2 was average.
Season 3, though. Season 3 is where it all went wrong. I’m not sure what exactly was going through the heads of the production team when they thought that it would be a good idea to reintroduce the Replicators to the show. I presume they were off their heads on coke or something. The Replicators, for those of you who don’t know, were a race of robotic spiders in Stargate SG-1 who roamed the galaxy like a swarm of locusts, using any resources they could find to make copies of themselves. Then, one day, some obviously mentally impaired writer decided that it would be more fun if replicators started building themselves to look like humans and, instead of replicating, killed things. Thankfully these new replicators were killed off quite quickly and I thought we would be spared any more intrusion by them.
But no. Rather than think up a new and original villain to pit the Atlantis team against, the writers decided that they’d have them find a planet full of Replicators. How bloody original is that?! They even conveniently ignore the (far superior) origin story for the Replicators as was established in SG-1. No, apparently they were no longer built by a lonely little girl who was too emotional to stop them doing harm, they were built as weapons by the Ancients (the stock background story for any sort of plot device in Atlantis).
Series 3 also introduced that oh-so-overused Atlantis plot element, the reset button. In one episode it turns out the Ancients weren’t extinct at all, they were just flying about in a damaged spaceship. The team rescued them and they came to take back Atlantis. Now, an event like this should have been some sort of massive, universe shattering revelation with repercussions lasting entire series. After all, it was established back in the first series of SG-1 that the Ancients were long gone. But no, the writers decided that rather than deal with such an important event, they’d have all the Ancients die… OFFSCREEN… before the end of the episode. Two episodes later, everyone was back to acting completely normal as if nothing had ever happened.
Not only that, season 3 is the season when they killed off Carson Beckett… WITH AN EXPLODING TUMOUR. Sounds ridiculous, doesn’t it? You’re probably wondering how they could justify killing off such a beloved character in such a ridiculous way. I’m wondering the same thing. It was, by far, the worst episode in the history of all of Stargate. I suppose it doesn’t matter too much though. They reset-buttoned the whole thing in season 4 and brought him back as a clone.
Don’t get me started on Season 4, just imagine that big reset button being pushed over and over again and a clichéd plotline about Teyla being pregnant with some magical baby and you’ll get an idea what it was like. Nothing of particular importance happens, so I’ll skip to Season 5.
Season 5, the final series. A final chance to see all our favourite characters in action. But what’s this? No, we’re not going to focus on your favourite, well established, galaxy wandering team. We’re going to do a big drawn out plot about some doctor character who nobody cares about and who’s inexplicably attracted to Rodney McKay. Now, I think Rodney McKay is a brilliant character, and can be very funny IN MODERATION, but devoting practically an entire series to him is just ridiculous! Sure, Sheppard still had a relatively big part in events, but Teyla and Ronin seemed to just sit in the background in cafeteria scenes and then disappear for the rest of the episode. Presumably they were off on far more exciting adventures than the rom-com we were being forced to put up with.
Then it came to the last episode. It was by no means the worst episode I’ve seen. It was probably one of the best of the last three seasons. For those of you who don’t want the plot spoiled, this is your chance to stop reading. So, anyway, the team discover that a gigantic Wraith ship is heading for earth and decide to power up the city’s engines and fly after it. So far, so good. “But wait!” you say, “Doesn’t earth have that big underground chair thing that launches yellow explodey balls? Why don’t they use that?” Well, the writers decided to close that little loophole by blowing it up…. in possibly the most under-dramatic scene ever. There’s an unstoppable battleship attacking the planet and their only defense has been destroyed and the most you get from the actors is “Oh fiddlesticks, at least we tried out best!” followed by one of those half-assed, “John Sheppard does a suicide run at a Wraith ship with a nuke but is rescued just in time” plots that they stick in every three episodes. In fact, I can’t think of another way they’ve ever destroyed a Wraith ship.
But the biggest sin of the final episode was probably the worst use of the reset button I have ever seen. Let me set the scene. The team are pinned down by the Wraith. One of them has grabbed Rodney. Within seconds he’ll be history. Ronin is engaged in a fight with another wraith. Seeing his friend in trouble, he momentarily ignores his opponent to save him and gets stabbed in the lung as a consequence. He lies on the floor coughing up blood as the rest of the team realise there’s no way they can save him. With his last breath, he tells them to go on and finish the mission. Emotional stuff….. Two scenes later he’s back on his feet.
Yes, it seems that the wraith decided to bring him back to life for questioning, but decided it would be best not to place guards on the doors or anything. That would just prevent the inevitable rescue scene, after which everything is back to normal.
Well, back to normal except that Atlantis is now on earth, but I’m sure they’ll reset that in the inevitable DVD movie. Personally, I think Atlantis should have ended as a series as soon as they re-established contact with earth, but I guess I’m not writing it so my opinion counts for squat. I just hope they do a better job with this new Stargate Universe show. Or even better, bring back SG-1!